Defence invokes poet Iqbal in Tahawwur Rana’s favour
By Mayank Chhaya, IANSThursday, December 3, 2009
CHICAGO - Pakistan’s poet laureate Allama Iqbal was invoked in a Chicago court to establish the “non-violent and decent” character of Tahawwur Hassan Rana, who is under detention pending indictment for aiding a conspiracy to “murder and maim” outside the US.
Appearing for this third bond hearing in an orange prison suit Wednesday, Rana looked visibly at ease as the prosecution and defence presented diametrically opposite portraits of the Canadian citizen of Pakistani origin. The three character witnesses brought by Rana’s attorney Patrick Blegen maintained he was a peace-loving, non-violent man who was interested in the message of Iqbal.
Mohammed Arshad Mirza, a Chicago ophthalmologist and an acquaintance, spoke of their common interest in the teachings of Iqbal as members of the Iqbal Society. “Iqbal’s message (to Muslims) was to be organised and educated and put their demands through legal means and never in an extra judicial non-violent manner,” Mirza told Magistrate Judge Nan Nolan in US District Court.
He was there to buttress Belgen’s argument that the image of Rana as presented by the US government was “inconsistent” with his client’s belief in Iqbal’s teachings. At one point as those present in the court wondered who Iqbal was Belgen said it was like saying that Gandhi’s followers would be violent.
The other two witnesses were Raja Mohammad Yaqub, a gasoline retailer, and Athar Akhtar, Rana’s brother-in-law. Both men maintained that the accused was a non-violent man not given to any of what he is being accused of. Yaqub said during a meeting of some 20 Pakistani American businessmen in Chicago last Sunday there was a general consensus that Rana was a peaceful man and needed to be supported by the community. Rana’s brother-in-law Akhtar said: “I believe he is a non-violent person.”
In contrast to Belgen’s argument, Assistant US Attorney Dan Collins said the character witnesses did not know that there was a “whole other side” to the accused.
“He spent a significant amount of time with (David Coleman) Headley — a lot more time than the three witnesses who were put here today,” Collins said. “The word ‘target’ is that man’s word, it came out of his mouth,” Collins said, pointing to Rana. His assertion was based on a recorded phone call.
Collins repeatedly asked the witnesses if they would change their opinion of Rana being a non-violent and peaceful man if they were to find out that he spent time with someone who had connections and trained with the Lashkar-e-Taiba, a “designated terrorist organisation”. None of the three offered a direct answer but said they had to know all the facts even as they emphasised that the accused was a non-violent man.
The US Attorney’s office has maintained that Rana was aware of Headley’s alleged intentions to carry out reprisal against the Danish newspaper cartoonist Kurt Westergaard, whose caricature of the prophet Mohammed wearing a bomb as a turban, in the Jyllands-Posten in 2005 triggered worldwide rage among Muslims.
The two are also under cloud for their alleged connection with the Mumbai terror attacks of November 2008 but that aspect has not been the focus of the current hearing. There was a mention of whether the reference to the National Defence College was the one in India or in Pakistan. The prosecution has maintained it refers to the one in India while the defence has denied it.
The defence also dismissed the prosecution’s contention over whether Rana agreed with some of the evidently radical Islamic materials that Headley had supplied him. “It is clear that Rana does not agree with things that Headley gave him. I have a copy of the Communist Manifesto at home. That does not mean I am a communist,” Belgen said.
It was disclosed during the hearing that Rana gave a five-hour statement to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) after his arrest. Saying that she would go watch the entire video statement Judge Nolan said she would “like to do a good job” because she is “the only judge Mr. Rana has got”. Belgen maintained that in that statement his client had denied any involvement in any plot.
Since his arrest Oct 3, Rana’s family has not been able to meet him, a delay attributed to paperwork. The decision whether to release him on a million dollar bond was postponed to Dec 15.
February 9, 2010: 3:50 pm
Giving without reserve It is with reticence that I write this. I do not wish to place myself on the moral high ground, or to sermonise anyone. This chapter tries to show the truth and importance of dreaming of our Holy Prophet Muhammad . These words seek to confirm that ours is a Prophet of Mercy, a Witness, and a Bearer of Good Tidings. It also aims to portray the consequence of da’wāt in the Masjid al-Harām. It is moreover meant as a method of encouragement for our children to some day continue with the Prophetic Tradition of raising an orphan for the sake of Allāh, The One of Unbounded Grace. So that they may by this means know that there is more to life than just prayer and fasting. And that they should give of themselves unreservedly. That they might through it also, temper their adhkār with compassion. We were asleep at the Mashrabiyya Hotel in Khalid bin Walīd Street in Shubayka, Makkah al-Mukarramah when, by the Mercy of Allāh, I had the most beautiful dream. I saw myself standing in the holy presence of our Truthful Prophet Muhammad . The appearance of the Holy Messenger of Allāh matched scriptural records. Al-hamdu-lillāh. I had never considered myself deserving of such an enormous honour. This was a spiritual experience of the first magnitude. “What does that smile mean?” I wondered. “Why is our Heroic Prophet Muhammad so extremely pleased?” I asked myself over and over again. I stared at the House of Allāh for extended periods, contemplating its meaning. Deep in thought, I barely noticed the usually persuasive central-African women selling bird-seed as I walked back and forth from the Masjid al-Harām. I was hardly aware of the Turkish female who was dealing in steel daggers on the side of the street. Two men earnestly collecting on behalf of Bosnian refugees also failed to draw my attention. I half-heard a Pakistani lad calling out the price of bottled perfume to prospective customers alongside the road. Malaysian girls trading informally with scarves only just caught my eye. Part of the street had been freshly tarred. “Unless you receive the sort of treatment that a host bestows on a guest, don’t ever think that, because you have performed the ziyārah of the Baitullāh, you’ve been the guest of Allāh,” my father had once counselled me. Every Muslim who had walked on the holy soil had the potential for such an experience, I realised. Such incidents might have been more prevalent than was ordinarily heard of, I thought. I had for a long time suspected that at least some pilgrims who repeatedly visited the Holy Land, apart from drawing from its built-in holiness, did not preclude themselves from offerings of this nature. It would be silly to think that parallels could not be drawn with al-Madinah al-Munawwarah in occurrences of this kind. It would also have been reasonable to expect wondrous incidents of this nature to occur in Jerusalem, as the major Middle Eastern religions agreed on the sanctity of this, the City of the Farthest Mosque. Thinking that this sort of happening was in any way unique to myself, was ludicrous. Part of my da’wāt in the Holy Mosque in Mecca, was to ask Allāh, The One Who Makes Clear to us His signs so that we may be grateful, to Grant to ourselves the opportunity and blessings of raising an orphan for His sake. Having the money with which to afford to go on Haj has always been its first consideration. There were many people who had performed the Holy Pilgrimage more often than I. With regard to my parting from the Holy City, though, I had received a fascinating send-off. My wife and I had, over a number of years, tried to adopt a baby by applying at several local agencies, and were given all sorts of excuses which disqualified, and sometimes discouraged us. Reasons given were that we were not married according to South African law, that few babies from local Muslim parents came up for adoption, and the fact that we have children of our own. We were also faced with, what was to my mind, the worse aspect of the South African race laws. These regulations and those administering it, in this case, the social workers, prescribed that a ‘brown’ orphaned child had to be matched with ‘brown’ adoptive parents. A ‘yellow’ baby could only be placed with prospective ‘yellow’ adoptive parents, a ‘white’ orphan could not be raised by ‘black’ adoptive parents, and so on. They played dominoes with human lives. Some social workers were more ready to read the ‘race act’ than others. On the morning of Wednesday, 1st June 1994, just three days after arriving back home from Haj, we received a telephone call from Melanie Van Emmenes of the Child Welfare Society. She explained that a five-month old girl had come up for adoption. The baby had earlier undergone successful abdominal surgery and she asked whether we would adopt the child. We jumped at the chance. A rush of adrenaline replaced the after-effects of travel. We were rejuvenated. Capetonians usually visit local pilgrims before departure and also on their arrival back home. We excused ourselves from the few visitors and asked my mother-in-law to host them in our absence. My wife and I immediately went to the Adoption Centre in Eden Road, Claremont. We signed the necessary papers. Afterwards, we told our children that we were about to receive an addition to the family. We plodded through a maze of red tape in order to legalise the process. (My wife and I had to marry in court because Muslim marriages were not recognised then, believe it or not). A few days later, my wife, brother and I collected the petite infant from a foster-mother in Newfields Estate. I shall never forget the joyous feeling when I first carried the frail waif past the front door. Her name is Makkia. We named her after the great city from which we had just returned. I shall always be grateful to the people who had assisted us with the adoption. In a letter of recommendation to the social workers, Haji Achmat Lalkhen al-Qādirī al-Chisti wrote that he could vouch for my decent parents. Sheikh Mogammad Riefaard bin Moegsien Manie al-’Alawi al-Qādirī al-Chisti had stated as a character reference that I was ‘of sober habits’. Taking her into our modest home is one of the better things that we have done. Makkia has added a marvellous dimension to our lives. She is part of our life’s-work. Adoption is a superb act of charity and the most effective form of da’wah. If every able married couple took on an orphan, the world would be a better place. Raising an orphan means giving from the innermost recesses of one’s heart. Adoption springs from the soul of the adoptive parent. We cry when a child is orphaned. God cries more. The meaning behind the glowing smile from our Trustworthy Prophet Muhammad had played itself out in the most delightful way. My dream shows our Prophet’s level of awareness and highlights his profound love for orphans and how kindly he looks on raising an orphan. It demonstrates that raising an orphan is an immensity before God. In our Prophet we have a beautiful pattern of conduct. Our Affectionate Prophet Muhammad , also, had raised a destitute child. Our Divinely-inspired Prophet is the first of the God-fearing. No person is better than him. He had scaled the peak of human tenderness. Our Prophet Muhammad is the leader of the prophets. He is without sin. Our Faultless Prophet is the foremost of those who submit to the Will of Allāh. An exemplar to those who worship God, our Kind-hearted Prophet Muhammad is the beacon of the pious. Religion is a feature that has encompassed all cultures throughout history. He had brought a religion of kindness and peaceful coexistence. Like a lamp that spreads light, the Messenger of Allāh invites to the Grace of Allāh by His leave. He is an inspiration to those who are thankful to God and the leader of those who remember Allāh . How should I express gratitude to the Holy Messenger of Allāh for his kind intervention? I am unworthy of untying the thongs of our Prophet’s sandals. From the Sahīh al-Bukhāri, Volume 7, Hadīth Number 224, translated from Arabic: From the Sahīh al-Bukhāri, ‘the Good Manners’ (Al-Adab), Volume 8, Book 73, Hadīth Number 34, translated from Arabic: From the Sahīh al-Muslim, Chapter 3: ‘Benevolent Treatment to the Widows, Orphans and the Poor’, Book 42, Hadīth Number 7108, translated from Arabic: From the Muwatta of Imam Mālik ibn Anas, the section called: ‘The Sunnah on Hair’, Book 51, Hadīth Number 51.1.5, translated from Arabic: May Allāh, The One Who Befriends the righteous, Send His Richest Peace and Blessings Upon our Holy Prophet Muhammad and On his family and companions, as much and as often as Allāh Wills. Allāh, The One Who Is Sufficient For those who put their trust in Him, Had Accepted our prayers and Granted our want through the barakah of our Beloved Prophet Muhammad . I’ve been fairly constant about wearing a turban during ’ibādāt since. |
Abdullah bin Abdurahman al-Qādirī al-Chisti al-Athloni